[Sovled] Chiseling the forge

[rontrabaroe 0]

It has come to my attention that the forge can be chiseled in certain instances but not in others. Now what I mean by the forge being chiseled is the front block between where the PC stands and where the charcoal is located. My above ground forge had no issues with the front  block being chiseld right next to the lit charcoal, yet my underground forge is being a cocksucker and just cant handle any chiseled block whatsover. It disappears(charcoal) completely when the block is chiseled.

[DcNdrew 10]

Because when you click on the stone with a chisel, it became a "chiselled block". The forge block on the block update start for search on solid blocks arount itself, but there are none, the chiselled block doesn't count as one. It's the same chiselled block if you use stone or even wood, as I understand, and so you could make forge by even wood planks which are a bit interesting. Or you could just leave one little knot next to the forge block, prevent it fell apart... Eh. So nope, you can't make it so.

[rontrabaroe 0]

The part that confuses me is how it DOES work when above ground. I'll get an account so I can upload a picture

[rontrabaroe 0]

 

[DcNdrew 10]

The part that confuses me is how it DOES work when above ground. I'll get an account so I can upload a picture

 

Yep, that's interesting. I've done it above the ground too, with paved block, but I had no luck.

[EstebanLB 183]

Dude, that forge needs more open space

[Caelann 1]

I don't know if this is intended or not but it'd be nice if it were kept, it looks pretty nice for decorative purposes.

[rontrabaroe 0]

Strange thing being as soon as I chisel the one in the bottom picture, the charcoal disappears. The above picture is obviously fine with a chiseled block in the front.

[theubie 19]

When you say "chisel" are you using the single pane/slab setting or the microblock/3d setting on the chisel?  A block that has the slab treatment done to it is considered an open air block on the side that's been slabbed, but on any side that is still full height and flush with the edge of it's block is considered solid to that side.  

 

From what I remember, when you use the microblock setting, the whole block (all 8 sides) instantly is considered an open air block.

[JaySparrow 0]

Ok, so I did some testing with 78.16 and here is what I discovered:

 

I went underground to test it just to be sure but this also happens above the ground.

When you chisel the block from NORTH-SOUTH direction the forge will vanish but from EAST-WEST it does not.

 

Why you ask? It's simple. TFC is considering the opposite side as an air block when chiseling (from NORTH-SOUTH or SOUTH-NORTH) and then you can do this:

 

 

If I chisel the block in the other direction this happens, and then kills the forge:

 

Before:

 

After:

 

Edit:

I believe this is  a bug so change the title of  the topic to: [78.16]Bug Chiseling and forge    or something like that.

 

JaySparrow.

[landryx 36]

/

[Kittychanley 1,002]

This should be fixed in 78.17