Unbalanced Wall recipe (build 75)

[aliceingame 114]

In creative mode I noticed that it't possible to create walls with many types and form of stone. So in my survival game, I decided to make some pieces of wall to make the top of my forge/bloomery chimney (good looking and prevent mobs from entering by the chimney)... however, the recipe is not exactly the same as in Vanilla. Well, the recipe is the same, but not the number of wall pieces created. You only get one piece of wall out of the original 6 pieces of stone.

In my opinion, it's odd that you need 6 pieces of stone to make one piece of wall (instead of 6 pieces like in Vanilla). I can not imagine any valid argument to support this recipe.

I guess it could be a quick fix for build 76.

[-TK- 49]

You mean stone brick wall? You can make that with a 1 to 1 ratio using rocks and a chisel.

[Mephistos_chan 26]

As the vanilla wall has some good mechanics, but terrafirma usually requires the use of a chisel to achieve the desired effect may I suggest that vanilla recipe is modified to give 6 wall pieces but that the chisel is req'd and take wear damage? This should also reduce some of the system overheads caused by lots of chiselled blocks.

[turtletechy 37]

You mean stone brick wall? You can make that with a 1 to 1 ratio using rocks and a chisel.

I think you're thinking of stone bricks, not walls. You cannot make a wall without six full pieces. As such, they aren't very practical for use.

[aliceingame 114]

I think you're thinking of stone bricks, not walls. You cannot make a wall without six full pieces. As such, they aren't very practical for use.

I talk about wall. Same recipe and mechanic as fence but using cobblestone in vanilla. Can make these with many TFC blocks.

Chisseled block can be jumped over, not walls. Adding chissel to the recipe sound good enough. Or even change it for a recipe like the support beam with 2 stone and chisel.

[turtletechy 37]

I talk about wall. Same recipe and mechanic as fence but using cobblestone in vanilla. Can make these with many TFC blocks.

Chisseled block can be jumped over, not walls. Adding chissel to the recipe sound good enough. Or even change it for a recipe like the support beam with 2 stone and chisel.

It might be a good idea to work on your grammar a little, just saying.

[Credinus 17]

It seems like English probably isn't his/her primary language, I wouldn't jump to attacking their grammar so fast.

As far as he/she is saying, I completely agree. The stone "wall" blocks can be emulated using a chisel on just one stone brick block with the detail mode, so I really see no reason for the recipe that requires six blocks to only produce one "wall" block.

[Emris 156]

The only difference is, you can jump over a chiseled brick wall.

[aliceingame 114]

It seems like English probably isn't his/her primary language, I wouldn't jump to attacking their grammar so fast.

Thanks, in fact French is my primary language.

I have nothing else to say. Will wait for a possible change in future version.

[AlmightySquid 72]

Maybe completely remove the recipe. Instead, after you chisel a stone block to a specific shape, it basically turns into the respective stone type wall. It would fix the unbalanced recipe and it would reduce lag caused by too many chisel blocks.

[Aridhol 41]

Maybe completely remove the recipe. Instead, after you chisel a stone block to a specific shape, it basically turns into the respective stone type wall. It would fix the unbalanced recipe and it would reduce lag caused by too many chisel blocks.

I think that getting it to the right shape would be more complicated than just increasing the yield and adding chisel-damage to the recipe

[TDminecrafters 0]

I think that getting it to the right shape would be more complicated than just increasing the yield and adding chisel-damage to the recipe

Ahh, but how do you expect to shape a stone block without chiseling it? That would subtract from the realism of it all.

[Mephistos_chan 26]

Ahh, but how do you expect to shape a stone block without chiseling it? That would subtract from the realism of it all.

I don't think anyone in the world actually carves stone in situ to create a wall, these are all approximations for a game.