Content: Slate Blackcurrant Watermelon Strawberry Orange Banana Apple Emerald Chocolate Marble
Background: Slate Blackcurrant Watermelon Strawberry Orange Banana Apple Emerald Chocolate Marble
Pattern: Blank Waves Notes Sharp Wood Rockface Leather Honey Vertical Triangles
Welcome to TerraFirmaCraft Forums

Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to contribute to this site by submitting your own content or replying to existing content. You'll be able to customize your profile, receive reputation points as a reward for submitting content, while also communicating with other members via your own private inbox, plus much more! This message will be removed once you have signed in.

  • Announcements

    • Crysyn

      Only help if you can be helpful

      Hey All, A topic has come up of late in the IRC channel in regards to the general feel of the forums and the community that supports them. Things have progressed further than I would have liked with out this being addressed more publicly because I would much rather have snubbed this out sooner rather than later.. but I have been busy. Here is the general rule I would like people to follow: Wheaton's Law "Don't be a dick." Those of you from the IRC channel know that this is the only rule I ask people in there to follow and we generally have a good and lively time chatting about all manner of things. This is basic rule that just about everyone understands and I am going to expand it to the forums from here moving forward. If you can not help people in a helpful and polite manner then I simply ask you to stop. Now I generally take a back seat to moderating the forums as I like to participate in the suggestions forum fairly heavily at times and would rather do so as a forums user than a moderator. But I am also fairly well known for being the person who constantly puts their foot down and so I am stepping up and doing so on here. If you find yourself unable to respond to a message politely then I ask that you do not respond. This mostly focuses on the increasing level of hostility found within the Suggestion forum as well as the Server forum. I do not care if this is the 30th some odd time you have seen someone make the same suggestion. Or even if the new post on an older topic is one entry above the old one. I expect the members of this forum to respond politely to the user, new or old, and point to the older topic if it applies and even go the extra step to suggest they either add in new information or to summarize the outcome of the previous discussion based upon the new post's entry into it. That is what we are here for, that is why I close most topics instead of deleting them, so that they can be found and referenced down the road. The next topic is the slew of derailment attempts I have seen as of late. If you want to have fun and joke around that is what the off topic forum is for and pretty much anything goes there. I do not expect to read a suggestion thread and have to go through 3 pages of image memes people have shot back and forth. Quite simply this is a waste of my time to read and then have to clean up. Now for the summary. I am going to start taking a more active role, especially in policing the suggestion forum, and handing out warn levels to people whom I see doing this. These will be indiscriminate and applied not to just the first person who derails or is impolite on a topic or response, but to everyone whom follows the lead of that person. As I do not like doing things with out giving you all warning this post shall serve as that warning. If you have a desire to bring this topic up with me then I invite you to do so on the IRC channel. Lets raise the level of quality and grow the community. Let us not descend into the quality often found on the minecraft or league of legend forums. There is simply no need for that here. Be passionate about things, just do not be abusive.
    • Kittychanley

      Offline Servers

      Recently I've seen a few server listings showing up on the first page of the Servers forum that have been closed for an extended period of time, but have recently gotten a reply from a new member who didn't realize the server is offline. To help prevent this from happening in the future, it would be greatly appreciated if you could use the report function on the original post of any servers that have been confirmed as offline, so that the topic may be locked. If you are the admin of a server and plan on taking the server offline, please use the report function on the original post of your topic to let the TFC Staff know that the topic should be locked. If you are the admin of a server that has a locked topic, and would wish to bring the server back online, please use the report function on the original post of the topic to let the TFC Staff know that the topic should be unlocked. As always, please remember to follow rule #3 of the servers forum and update your topic title to contain the version of TFC that the server is currently running. You can do so by editing the OP, and then clicking on "Use Full Editor."


  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Darmo

  1. Fearsome Critters

    That's legacy stuff from vanilla minecraft. Granted, possibly the most successful, most poorly planned game ever, so I mean, who needs a theme right? But my own hope is that as TFC2 matures, those things will be much more limited, to logical scenarios. Though creepers are pretty hard to logic, imo. Suicidal powder-keg carrying goblins?
  2. Fearsome Critters

    For me on the other hand - coming from my Dungeons and Dragons background - trolls are lanky terrifying regenerating beasts that you can only kill with fire or acid, and have no special relationship with stone or sunlight. I didn't mean to say that referencing an existing ouvre is bad - it's actually a good game strategy, because your audience can immediately have familiarity (Orcs are evil pig-nosed humans. Dragons breath fire and hoard gold. Dwarves speak with a Scottish accent) which from a roleplaying and immersion standpoint allows them to more easily 'slot in' to the world. I was just pointing out it doesn't have to be that way, and moreover there are many ouvres to choose from. One way the devs could go is just say 'hey modelers, show us what you got'. And we'd each go with our personal favored stuff, and it could end up rather chaotic and incoherent. Another way, they could give a setting to pull from. Tolkien, D&D, Discworld, Classical Greek, etc. Should give a more coherent experience, though some settings would have an inherently limiting selection. Or there could be an idea. 'Guys, we're picturing a war between humans, fey, and devils. Go to work'. That sort of would allow us to cross several ouvres, but still work toward a coherent theme. I guess I'd prefer to see some kind of coherence, if not a theme/story, rather than just whatever enters our heads. But we'll see.
  3. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    I'd guess it's due to the new sand physics. If you hadn't noticed, sand now falls if it has *any* potential lower adjacent spot. It's no longer supported by two or even three adjacent blocks. All it takes is a block update. So there's a chance that there was sand in those spots, with reeds on top, and there was a empty trench adjacent, and the whole row of sand fell into it. Maybe.
  4. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    I think Konlii reported the same crash earlier. It seems to be a problem with the new tree types. Probably best to not try to go to the tropics until Bioxx resolves it.
  5. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    Found an interesting elevation mis-match going on at an inland desert lake. The 1-block change was pretty extensive. The 2-block difference was much more limited in scope. At the time I took those screencaps I hadn't yet noticed the journeymap coords were obscured by the island features list. But if you go to that seed, and go I think 1 island west, that's the island. You can use island coords from there. An interesting feature of these inland lakes is that, near as I can tell, they always have a large river exiting to the ocean. I love the level of river detail, where two rivers combining makes the subsequent river wider. It seems like every time a tributary gets added, another block in width is added to the successive river sections. I think the lake-to-ocean rivers are 8 blocks wide. I love that thoughtfulness of the world gen! Now I just wish we could have swamp estuaries at the mouths of rivers. @TonyLiberatto The next level of detail would be if there could occasionally be a pool of water below the stalagtites (instead of stalagmite)!
  6. Fearsome Critters

    Tolkienesque trolls maybe (or wherever Tolkien got it from). There's nothing that says TFC2's version of fantasy has to conform to a certain pre-existing fantasy ouvre. I think Konlii's version of a drop bear may have been a bit tongue-in-cheek.
  7. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    I see what you mean chunk. It seems pretty obvious that's a dungeon. And amazing at that! I love the room variety! It's interesting too, the strip of grass along the waters edge in that area. I flew over much of the rest of the island and did not see that, though I did see little river valleys with a river, and all the hexes the river flowed through were grass. Amazing! Personally I think it's great to have a start seed like this once in awhile. Some people really love hard starts. I noticed in this desert seed that occasionally there was andesite sand mixed in with the prevailing chert. I thought it must be a glitch with the falling sand mechanic, but you can see in the one picture there is a dead bush growing on top of the andesite sand, so it must not have fallen there right? The last picture is a large area with a cave underneath that caused a massive sand cave-in. It had by far the most andesite sand I'd seen, which is why I thought it might have to do with the falling mechanics. Also in the temple structure I noticed this graphical glitch with a stair block Regarding the chisels mechanic, I've come to peace with it maybe not making it in. I'm actually glad that stairs will be a proper block, because it always bothered me a bit in TFC1 that on servers with dynmap, chiseled blocks were invisible, so that the finely chiseled roofs didn't show up on the map. It made town look really messy on the map for the most part, because you just saw their walls and chest and junk sitting around.
  8. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    Each island region does have it's own seed, which is separate from the world seed itself. The region seed is what you're seeing in the creative mode screen, I think.
  9. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    Those are a geographical feature called 'spires' (if you play in creative, you'll see a list of 'island features' at the top right). Near as I can tell they're supposed to be a natural formation. They could probably use some work to look a bit more natural though. As for food, I think it's reasonable to assume that in this early alpha stage, the food balance is not what it will be in the end. Bioxx has said in tweets you'll be better off in creative for now. I actually welcome the scarcity of gardens. I'm hoping it means there will be a more foraging-focused playstyle in the beginning, while one builds up a stock of seeds to settle down with. Hunting and gathering type stuff. For me, one of the most interesting aspects is what I *haven't* seen yet, and that is even a speck of surface (or cave, for that matter) lava. I'm hoping this bodes well for there being a rare volcano feature. Issues-wise, I noticed that ash trees at least, seem to have a lot of floating leaf blocks. I wonder if their schematics need examined? Also, the last two worlds I've played, I headed north (since apparently the tropics are bugged, from what Konlii posted). And both times I again ran into the thing where the next island north of my starting temperate island, was also temperate. Following area again two screen shots showing me first on one side of the region boundary, then to the north. Still showing "temperate" under island parameters. Also of note is that the island (it was very large, but I think separate from the main island) was within 20 blocks of the region boundary, and you can see the steep change in underwater topography. I mention this in case the generation parameters need tuning to keep players away from the boundary. I don't know what measures are planned to keep them away, but right now it'd be very easy to see from shore there, and even reach, unless the forbidance mechanic is to actually physically wall them off, or have a big wave wash them backwards whenever they get close, or something. The above three screenshots were all in the seed chunk posted, btw (the first one he posted from the region, not the corrected world one). Also, bears have a REALLY high leg swing. Could perhaps use some adjusting downward a tad?
  10. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    I gave a link in that other thread you started with the same question, but thought I'd also put it here, for anyone else here with the same questions. This link takes you to an early 2016 post I made, that summarized some of the very early posts in mid-2015, wherein Bioxx clued us in to his plans, including all this island and portal stuff. We were given the info in bits and pieces in several different threads, usually following an OP of a completely different topic. If you want to skim it, just do a browser search for "Bioxx", and it'll help you find his posts in some of the more extensive threads.
  11. Islands? Basic systems here?

    Here a link to a post where I give several links to some of the early days (mid-2015) discussions about TFC2. We were kind of given the information on the island plan in bits here and there in separate threads. You'll probably have to visit several threads to get the complete original picture.
  12. Swamps Suggestion

    I feel like that may be a bit far-reaching, if any and every bog tile had such a possibility just for walking on it. But if there's swarms of insects that the player can see, avoid, or take repellent measures against, that's something the player can understand and react to, and I think would go over better.
  13. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    I also noticed that in caves, sometimes large areas of natural stone collapse, with no molestation or block updating actions on my part. Apparently this is where the cobble and gravel I've been seeing are coming from. Does this mean that the collapse code is currently in game? And intended to stay? It seems to help clear out perhaps 'odd' floating stuff in caves, but not all.
  14. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    To update my previous post, I did another world (1.4) and correctly went from temperate to sub-tropical. Don't know if that was fixed in update, or if it only happens occasionally or something. The flying around takes awhile, and does cause crashes at times, so it takes awhile to test. Found some small swamps too, though nothing as big as the twitter pic way back when.
  15. Mobs for TFC2

    We're kind of at a pause in mob modeling right now, as Bioxx has a large back-log of mobs already that we've made, but are not implemented. He's just not at the point where mobs are the priority yet. I'm pretty sure he has implemented several new mobs from the early days, when it was just me and Alpha and Phineas. But I think most of the stuff in the public forum probably hasn't been inserted yet. So some patience will be required. We've focused on ground-based mammals and birds pretty much exclusively, because Bioxx can just copy the animations easily from vanilla mobs. Anything that flies, or has weird motion (like a snake) is going to be way down the list due to the animation issues. All that said, 5 of the animals you mentioned are already made and modeled, 2 or 3 of which I think *might* be inserted in the game already. I haven't actually seen any of the new mobs yet (though I've seen one vanilla mob that was not in TFC1!). Most of the rest you mentioned are already on 'the list'.
  16. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    So I headed to Z=0 to see the tropics, and apparently z0 is actually the north edge of the tropical zone, not the middle. But what struck me was that I had two temperate islands in a row (this is all according to the creative info in screenies) and then went directly to tropical. See following two screen shots, one of which is just north of z0, and one is just south. I'd sort of expected z0 to be in the middle of the tropical island, but I guess that part doesn't make a huge difference. More about the skipping a climate. Unless of course the info is just incorrect. The trees seemed temperate-plausible, but I'm not sure what the parameters are. For those wondering, ore veins are indeed in the game. I've found both Bismuth (of course), and garnierite! The bismuth is the greyish stuff in the small tunnel. The garnierite the bit of green at the bottom of the large cave shot. Apparently this time the thing with ore texture being overlaid over native stone isn't a thing? Or it's just not implemented yet? And I have to say, the larger caves are gorgeous! I love the addition of cobble and gravel to mix up the feel (or maybe those are just artifacts of generating near the surface), and the abundance of stalags. Mobs everywhere. Huge dangerous areas not easily blocked off. There's also normal size tunnels too. But the large caves are the great part, and they can go on for quite awhile at large size too! Also there appears to be some kind of combination grass-on-top-of-stone commonly found at cave mouths and in valleys. I love this detail, it makes for a good transition from the grassy lands above, to the stark caves below. (these screenshots are from 0.1.0, so they still have some dirt-hanging stalagtites) I never did see the "even sharper mountains" on the one island, but I did find a valley, and it was magnificent, with a nice big lake at the mouth. Too big to really get a good screenshot of though. The sometimes straight cliff faces kind of bugged me a bit, but they're growing on me. Beaches do often have very pronounced circular cuts, but I think it's only really noticeable from up high. I'd really love it if someone could post a screenshot/seed with a swamp near spawn.
  17. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    Oh, that's a vanilla biome indicator. Gotcha. For reference for a suggestion I'm considering, can the hex biome data be used in things outside generation? For instance when placing plants, or checking plant growth? Or is it non-accessible after generation is done?
  18. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    I thought biomes in TFC1 (and kind of expected in TFC2) dictated terrain type? Hills are hilly, mountains more so, plains are flatt-ish? I thought swamp biome meant there should be probably a lake(s)? and a lot of flat terrain around, at about sea level. The part that surprised me wasn't the soggy garden (for all I know they just generate wherever and that's the plan) as that I was up at 100y in a swamp biome. But I guess if biomes don't even influence terrain now, then nothing to see here...but I could have sworn the hex maps you posted long ago had different terrain or biomes or something?
  19. [0.1.11] TFC2 Prerelease

    After a few very brief 1-day playthroughs in survival, I noticed that I can start knapping with only one rock. But then when I start removing pieces the texture disappears (grey pattern area remains though), and I can't actually get an output. But would probably be best if I cannot start knapping with just one rock. I also couldn't figure out how to make firestarter. Love the streams with gravel banks! I can't be sure but I found some food in the vicinity of another garden, by a stream. I don't know if the water destroyed a garden and left the food, or what, but it appeared that a couple other gardens had been destroyed by the environment somehow. The food was sitting on the gravel bank by a stream, so maybe it generated a garden on gravel which then wasn't a valid base and it despawned? At one point I found a soggy garden on a hill at elevation 100, and noticed that according to f3 I was in a swamp biome. Not sure if that's desired? I didn't really try to investigate just how large the swamp biome was, to see if any part at all of it looked more swampy. The hill was rather large, and one side was beach and what appeared to be ocean. So there was nothing obviously swampy looking in the immediate area where I found the garden. No cattails yet, it seems? Or maybe I just didn't find any freshwater lakes... I too found some minor water issues. One where two flowing blocks were not flowing over and down, and another where one block of water appeared different. I didn't have waila installed and only later realized f3 gives info about what you're looking at, so I'm not sure if it was a random vanilla block, or what. I also noticed grass is generating on the rock floor of ravines, and cave openings. Not sure if that's intentional? What little I've seen of caves are awesome, btw! Though I did just notice after posting that screenshot, the top left stalagtite appears to be hanging from dirt? I did notice at some ravine lips, there were stone blocks neighbored only by dirt, where it was starting to 'curve back over'. Kind of minor I guess. Can hardly wait till tonight to do some creative fly-throughs!!!
  20. Giant Centipede

    That's nice. Pincers are a nice add! I even like the color scheme better. Final word isn't really up to me though, as I'm not the one animating it. My fear is that it may look too wooden; I'm assuming it's not really possible to animate it bending in a dynamic way (that is, responding to turns and corners). I imagine it can be animated to undulate like a snake, but I don't think that's really how they move. Bioxx will have to weigh in on it.
  21. Giant Centipede

    Aaaand I just noticed I totally missed the part where you planned on scaling it down. My bad. 5 meters is still pretty large though. Did you try building the model at the intended scale? I realize your leg tips are probably what governed the size choice - they are indeed pleasingly spindly in relation to the body - but my experience has been that making double size textures is kind of pain, if you want to modify it afterward...
  22. Giant Centipede

    Good Lord Konlii, you don't shy away from going big do you? I agree on legs being a big part of the creep factor, though I think it's more important if the legs are actually articulated. If they're just a rigid structure, less so. In general I am of the opinion that it's ok for more aggressive and 'fantasy' mobs to be more complicated. I would think we'd want them to be impressive and scary. I had planned to have this conversation when Bioxx asked for fantasy mobs, or giant insects. If he wants to have it now, we may as well. As for commentary, I probably would have tried to get by with 3 segments per leg at most. And I don't know that the extra ridge boxes are all that worth it. Assuming it's mainly for z-fighting issues, could you not have just tilted the body segments in their entirety that same amount, to avoid the issue? Rather than adding barely-protruding tilted boxes? I'd also probably consider swapping the antennae for large menacing mandibles. Antennae just don't say 'I'm a-gonna poison and eat you!' But my main concern is the animating of it on Bioxx's part (would it undulate, or just move in a stiff arrow-straight fashion?), and then the possible (probable?) movement and clipping issues. I'm not sure how minecraft's hitboxes work, but I question if that entire length can be a hitbox, and if so, what happens when the centipede tries to turn in a narrow tunnel? The model is like, 10 meters long. You're going to at *least* have large portions of the body clipping out of the tunnel walls, unless the animation and collision detection is a lot better than I think it is. What if you could sort of have it rearing up in an S shape, to reduce the floor area it takes up to like, 1x3 meters max or something? I think you could use most or all of that body length, but just have it be bunched up. It's probably also be more threatening if taller. Overall, it probably would have been better to have started with a more 'normal' proportioned insect. But let's see what Bioxx says.
  23. Glass works

    FYI, there does exist another thread specifically about Clay Working. Wood lathe, I'm not sure there's enough potential products for that. Bowls, yes. Jars? I've never heard of wood jars in a historical sense. I have a hard time coming up with anything else that isn't just decorative, excepting perhaps pulley sheaves. Glass blowing through moulds would definitely be much simpler to code. The chemistry of the glass could actually be a good tech tree. So one could start with simple glass, that maybe gets used up faster, or do more durable glass types, or ones that are required for large items, etc.
  24. Weapons, sheats, and ranged weapons

    Re Stroam' s ideas: I'd agree that cost is not a huge factor. Unless cost is significantly different in TFC2 from TFC1. TFC1, cost is either 1 ingot or two ingots. That's it, and given the size of ore veins, after you find your first vein of ore it's no longer really a factor. Now, if TFC2 brought it other factors - for instance two-handed swords take multiple smithing steps and/or have to be tempered - that would help make there be an actual practical cost difference, in terms of time and fuel. But 100 units of metal more or less is, to me, nothing (unless TFC2 ore gen is different, which from what we've seen so far, I don't think it will be). You've got 5 different cost categories there and I'm wondering how you're thinking of defining them. I'd question classifying a two-handed sword as slash+blunt. I think that's probably stretching it a bit. Actually dividing the damage between types on dual-damage weapons is an interesting take, and would help in the balancing vs two separate and entirely equal damages. I still think it unnecessarily complicates things. I'm questioning why one would even have a dagger, with such low damage and range. At that point why not just call it a knife, and it's the tool players carry to cut things? And if they're forced to fight with it, god speed. Unless of course, extenuating circumstance are involved. Killing mobs with a ritual knife to trap their soul for instance. Energy use, good angle. Out of curiosity, does anyone know of any 1.8+ mods that successfully incorporate 2-handed attacks? With correct animations? I'm having trouble imagining how that would animate successfully. Re: SnarkyKnight I'd suggest considering a chart like Stroam made. That is much more convenient for comparison. I also might suggest using numbers or letters, rather than hyphenated descriptors. Is "medium-low" the low end of medium, or the middle of low? It's unclear and muddies the discussion unnecessarily. I see you revised the OP. On the weapons and encumbrance front, I think one should be careful on that. Blanket speed debuffs are one of the most pernicious debuffs in video games, especially ones with large exploration components. I think it'd be a hard balancing act keeping 2-handed weapons good enough that people would want to use them, while being always encumbered by them. Juuuust in case you hadn't seen it, there is a thread about encumbrance, which Bioxx himself initiated, in which he was basically proposing the idea of all items having weight, and the player having a carry limit. In this scenario, perhaps giving 2-handed weapons a very high weight might be more reasonable than having them cause a blanket encumbrance? What if rather than a container-type item, there were simply 2 specialized slots to the left of the hotbar, by the shield, that only accept small and medium weapons? These slots only become active if the player is wearing a sheathe for EACH slot (put on and off in the inventory screen, like armor). This allows the player to scroll to those weapons, if they're not comfortable with hotkeys. The disadvantage of two-handed weapons would be that they cannot be used in sheathe slots, you have to carry them on your hotbar, BUT you DO have to have two sheathes on you (representing a back sheathe) AND they disable the shield slot. If you don't have sheathes, you can still carry them on your hotbar, but THEN they do encumber you significantly (or grey out 2 extra hotbar slots?). So effectively you have a 4-slot spread. You can carry two medium-small weapons AND a shield AND have 10 hotbar slots, or you can carry one two-handed weapon on your hotbar, with shield and sheathe slots all taken up by that one weapon. THAT would create very significant difference, and more easily justify higher damages for 2-handed weapons. You could perhaps extend that idea slightly by having a medium weapon take both sheathe slots. So then small weapons even have a slight advantage over medium, as far as inventory space goes, as you could carry two smalls in the sheathe slots. You could maybe even allow tools to be used in the sheathe slots. Knives, chisels, and propicks are small. Axes and hammers are medium. Saws and scythes can't use sheathe slots, but also don't require sheathes - they're just carried in inventory or hotbar normally. As far as quivers, TFC1 already has them, and the mechanics you're suggesting are a lot more restrictive and complicated. I feel like the current quiver works just fine, honestly. Not sure there's really a big need four three different kinds. Overall I'm still dubious about weapon range. I know it's huge in pvp, but I feel like vs. mobs, if the player can have too much melee range, you risk breaking the melee mechanic more than it already is, as far as the player reaching mobs that can't reach them. It would help balance it if ultra-ranged melee weapons actually cannot affect man-sized and smaller creatures that get to close to the player. In that way, small fast creatures would be a threat to pike-armed players. Overall though I think a max melee range of 2, for a spear, is a better idea. It's basically like vanilla, I think.
  25. Weapons, sheats, and ranged weapons

    Ya, I got the speed idea. It seems like a very D&D-influenced list. The problem is, minecraft/TFC mechanics are nothing like D&D. They don't have the granularity, combat is not turn-based, and enemies can't react as intelligently. Most mobs will either just face-tank you, or stay away. In those situations speed is not, in and of itself, a great differentiator. I don't have experience with the new combat system, that incorporates speed, so I'm speaking only from videos I've watched. But it doesn't really seem like speed makes a lot of difference, at least in vanilla. Because mobs are just to dumb. Now in pvp it can, but that's kind of a whole other story. At least, that's my impression. As far as armor, if you haven't already read it, I'd point you to the suggestion I made awhile back of a "tier vs tier" weapon and armor system. Bioxx responded positively, so there's a chance it may become the system. And it's got some major differences from vanilla. It actually is an advantage to a more granular weapon and armor system though, because base damage and armor values would be standardized by type, removing material from the balancing equation, making the balancing easier. The idea of being forced to carry large weapons in your inventory, vs smaller weapons in a sheathe, is the whole point of that idea. It allows you to give larger weapons more damage or other advantages, because they also have more disadvantages. The more advantages/disadvantages brought in to play, the easier it is to make a broad array of weapons, in theory, because you have more 'knobs' to adjust for each one. That particular sheathe idea has issues of it's own though, insofar as how do you quickly access the weapons inside? Because that warhammer in the sheathe will not be much help if you're surprised by a skeleton and have to go into your inventory and pull it out manually. But that's a detail, and not the point. The point is, think up little ideas that can play into the weapon advantage/disadvantage system. Don't just stick with the obvious stuff. If you limit yourself to just basic weapon stuff like speed and damage, you're inherently limiting the useful array of weapons. As a side comment, I know two-handed swords have a very popular place in mythology and fantasy. But everything I'm read, from a historical perspective, indicates that they were a highly specialized type of sword, used for a very limited time, in very limited circumstances - mostly with relation to polearms. Which isn't to say they shouldn't be part of a system - it's a fantasy game after all. But I'd prioritize weapons that were used more broadly, over longer time periods. Polearms themselves were a weapon used in mass formations, which minecraft just isn't about. I'd love to see them used by mobs in formation, but I doubt that's practical. I consider polearms different from spears though. Spears are arguably the oldest and longest-used constructed weapon mankind has ever had aside from perhaps a club, and should absolutely be in. Another advantage I'd suggest for polearms (and large weapons in general) is that extremely large creatures intrinsically take half damage from medium weapons, and 10% damage from small weapons. Simply put, you can't reach a giant's vital organs with a longsword. You're fighting his lower legs. That should be relatively easy to code vs a lot of other ideas (though it would lose some logic if the player's can at some point fly). Sort of in summary, it seems a bit like you're trying to take all the major fantasy weapons and give them a role. I think instead it'd be better if you develop a basic framework, and then expand only as far as you can create distinct advantageous roles. Perhaps don't try to shoehorn in weapons just because they existed once upon a time irl.